- Posts: 98
 - Thank you received: 4
 
Large difference between semicanonical & standard
- Nike
 - Topic Author
 - Offline
 - Premium Member
 - 
            
         
        Less
        More
        
            
    
        
            
        
                8 years 2 months ago                #413
        by Nike
    
    
 	
					
                                	
			
				    
            
            
            
            
            
                                
    
                                                
    
        Large difference between semicanonical & standard was created by Nike            
    
        Dear all,
The manual says "Iterative CC and CI methods are invariant to the choice of ROHF orbitals", but I have found a large difference for CISD, which doesn't involve (T), (Q), (P), or anything in parenthesis.
Oxygen atom aV8Z 366 functions
CISD -74.996 013 37 (Frozen-core Semicanonical)
CISD -74.996 035 45 (Frozen-core Standard)
Nitrogen atom aV8Z 366 functions
CISD -54.525 222 25 (Semicanonical)
CISD -54.525 259 92 (Standard)
I have attached a GENBAS along with all four output files (which include the inputs).
Actually it seems I can only add 3 attachments in one post, so I have only included the nitrogen atom
Am I doing something wrong, or have I found a bug, or am I interpreting the manual wrong?
With best wishes!
Nike
    The manual says "Iterative CC and CI methods are invariant to the choice of ROHF orbitals", but I have found a large difference for CISD, which doesn't involve (T), (Q), (P), or anything in parenthesis.
Oxygen atom aV8Z 366 functions
CISD -74.996 013 37 (Frozen-core Semicanonical)
CISD -74.996 035 45 (Frozen-core Standard)
Nitrogen atom aV8Z 366 functions
CISD -54.525 222 25 (Semicanonical)
CISD -54.525 259 92 (Standard)
I have attached a GENBAS along with all four output files (which include the inputs).
Actually it seems I can only add 3 attachments in one post, so I have only included the nitrogen atom
Am I doing something wrong, or have I found a bug, or am I interpreting the manual wrong?
With best wishes!
Nike
Attachments:
            	      
												
            	
            	Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Nike
 - Topic Author
 - Offline
 - Premium Member
 - 
            
         
        Less
        More
        
            
    
        - Posts: 98
 - Thank you received: 4
 
            
        
                8 years 2 months ago                #414
        by Nike
    
    
 	
					
			
				    
            
            
            
            
            
                                
    
                                                
    
        Replied by Nike on topic Large difference between semicanonical & standard            
    
        Attachments for Oxygen added here:    
    Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- kallay
 - Offline
 - Administrator
 - 
            
         - Mihaly Kallay
 
            
        
                8 years 2 months ago                #415
        by kallay
    
    
            
Best regards,
Mihaly Kallay
    
            
            
            
            
            
                                
    
                                                
    
        Replied by kallay on topic Large difference between semicanonical & standard            
    
        Dear Nike,
It is only true if all electrons are correlated. With frozen core the energies are slightly different since the frozen orbitals are not identical. I will correct the manual.
            It is only true if all electrons are correlated. With frozen core the energies are slightly different since the frozen orbitals are not identical. I will correct the manual.
Best regards,
Mihaly Kallay
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
        Time to create page: 0.040 seconds